Nov. 17, 2026

Commerce Riff with Sri & PVSB - November 17, 2026

Commerce Riff with Sri & PVSB - November 17, 2026
Commerce Riff with Sri & PVSB - November 17, 2026
The CPG Guys
Commerce Riff with Sri & PVSB - November 17, 2026

Each week, the CPG Guys will riff on the hottest topics in the world of omnichannel commerce.

This week’s topics:

  1. COMMERCE MEDIA’S CONSOLIDATION ERA IS HERE
  2. REDDIT TESTS AN AI-POWERED PRODUCT REVIEW PORTAL
  3. THE TRADE DESK CLEARS WALL STREET’S LOW EXPECTATIONS AS REVENUE STALLS
  4. WALMART ADDS 300 MORE DRONE DELIVERY SITES

CPG Guys Website: http://CPGguys.com

DISCLAIMER: The content in this podcast episode is provided for general informational purposes only. By listening to our episode, you understand that no information contained in this episode should be construed as advice from CPGGUYS, LLC or the individual author, hosts, or guests, nor is it intended to be a substitute for research on any subject matter. Reference to any specific product or entity does not constitute an endorsement or recommendation by CPGGUYS, LLC. The views expressed by guests are their own and their appearance on the program does not imply an endorsement of them or any entity they represent.

CPGGUYS LLC expressly disclaims any and all liability or responsibility for any direct, indirect, incidental, special, consequential or other damages arising out of any individual’s use of, reference to, or inability to use this podcast or the information we presented in this podcast.

PVSB

Welcome to Commerce Riff, the weekly look at what matters in commerce from the CPG guys. I'm PBSB. Joining me always is my co-creator and ride or die, Sri. Sri, what's going on in the left coast? How you doing?

Sri

Bright and sunny. This is the time of the year when we get the good weather. The rest of the country doesn't, but I'm excited because we have our share group this upcoming week. At the time this episode is released, we'll be in the middle of our first visit, you and me, the CPG guys, with Ken Coogan's Share Group, which we are taking over from January. And this is the digital e-commerce. Very excited. We're going to spend time with Pinterest, Uber Eats. Lots of fun stuff, man.

PVSB

Yeah, it should be fun. The Digital Marketing Share Group is going to be right in our wheelhouse, Sri. We're so excited to be carrying on the journey that Ken started almost 30 years ago. What a lot of fun that's going to be. For stories this week, Commerce Media enters its consolidation era. Reddit tests an AI powered product review portal. Just as holiday shopping kicks off the trade desk. Clears Wall Street's low expectations while revenue stalls. And Walmart adds 300 more drone delivery sites. Right, Sri?

Sri

Believable.

PVSB

Absolutely. All right. First up, Commerce Media Ad Week's Lauren Johnson said consolidation is finally coming to retail media, and the 2027 will be shaped by big moves from DoorDash, Delta, and da, McDonald's. Here's the setup. Since 2020, retailers and commerce players of all sizes have built advertising businesses, and there are now more than 250 retail media networks, according to the data firm MIMBY. For brands and agencies, managing partnerships with that many individual companies is laborious and expensive, which is why they've wanted consolidation for years. Sign one is DoorDash's pending $17 billion acquisition of Instacart, which we covered back in episode 55. It's poised to create a massive advertising play in the delivery space, competing directly with Uber. The deal isn't expected to close until late 2027, but advertisers have already welcomed it because they're getting more scale and data that either company provides on its own. Tenuities Elizabeth Marston calls it a true competitor, especially in last mile and delivery. Sign two is new networks. In September, McDonald's and Delta confirmed they're building networks to compete for ad dollars. And AdWeek subhead says McDonald's wants to build a $1 billion ad business. That means more platforms for advertisers to manage, but also valuable audience data. Adweek notes and McDonald's data could help non-food brands find very busy families. Sign three is what's coming. Marston expects many mid-year partnership agreements between non-competing networks, what she calls a three-for-one scenario. Businesses that don't overlap but serve the same shopper. Advertisers also want to reach shoppers beyond retail environments or streaming and the open web, and they want audience data beyond the transaction. Good way groups Bianca Finale said consolidation has already started. Maybe it's not retailer-led as it is tech-led. And the IAB's Colburn puts it this way: the ecosystem is expanding and consolidating simultaneously, with new players entering, while established networks look for greater scale and efficiency. What's our view? Well, Sharina, I think both things are true at once. More than 250 networks, and now McDonald's and Delta joining the party while the biggest players roll up. For brands, fewer contracts is a relief, but bigger platforms also means more concentration to negotiate with. The same tension we flagged on DoorDash and Instacart. And look at where the buyer already is. Last week I walked through Unilever's one Unilever media, which runs planning, buying data, and learning as one system with retail media AI across 44 retailers. The buy side is consolidating its operating model, and the sell side is finally catching up. What we'd recommend you watch, which non-competing networks pair up first and whether the measurement gets standardized across them. Sri, over to you.

Sri

Story two. No surprise. Holiday shopping season is kicking off, and then Reddit pulls a surprise. Is actually testing a dedicated portal for product reviews. It's called Reddit Reviews. It's come into Reddit's iOS and Android apps on the web, and it compiles existing Reddit conversations and products into review pages. It rolls out over the next few weeks according to a company blog post shared with Adweek. Somebody else was also on Adweek recently. I wonder who. The backdrop is Reddit's own research, which says half of US shoppers use Reddit to validate AI recommendations. We've known this to be true for quite a bit. At launch, it covers about 10,000 frequently discussed products across four categories: electronics, health, beauty, home and garden, fashion, apparel. Reddit's blog post points to skincare addiction where people share what they've tried for dry skin, espresso, where baristas and home brewers compare their actual setups. Here's how it works: people find reviews by searching a product or category by selecting a highlighted name in the comments. AI creates a short summary of the actual Reddit comments with a visual showing of how many of the conversations are positive, negative, or mixed AK sentiment analysis. And then links to an individual review in the subreddits. It also shows products people frequently compare for products with no reviews yet. Search gives an AI credit response based on Reddit conversations, right? It has also been testing links to product details in threads and dedicated product tabs on business profiles. Now, the part brands will care about most, which ad we calls not pay to play for now. A Reddit spokesperson said the products that appear are shaped by the communities and are not paid placements. Brands cannot pay to be featured, and this is separate from Reddit's test of ad placements and search. Ask whether ads will ever come to reviews. The spokesperson said at this stage our focus is to test and improve the experience for our users. When we learn more from the test, we'll continue to evaluate how the product should evolve. What is our lens on the CPG guys? This is the set by others quote unquote idea from Peter's Unilever write-up from last week. It used to mean people, and today it means people plus ELLMs and Reddit is where both go. If half of shoppers are checking AI answers against Reddit, then the review page is becoming an input to the shelf. You can't buy your way in. You earn it with product quality, community presence, and honest engagement. Two things to watch. First, that for now, and second, the title of a related ad week exclusive that says advertisers will soon be able to buy Reddit ads through Pacview. Reddit is clearly building both sides of the commerce. Lou. Over to you.

PVSB

Shank Sri, that's a great story. All right, story three: the trade desk beat low expectations, but revenue stalled. Third quarter revenue was $736 million, down 0.5% from a year ago, compared with 18% growth in the third quarter of 2025. They've still beat forecasts by about $85 million, helped by record political spending. And AdWeek notes political ads kept the decline from being steeper. What are they going to do next year when there is no year election? Headwinds are expected to resume in Q4, and the company guided fourth quarter revenue to $755 million. Profitability street took a big hit. Adjusted EBITDA was $266 million, a 36% margin down from $317 million and a 43% margin a year earlier. Net income was $38 million, down from $116 million, including $44 million in restructuring charges, primarily severance. Revenue for the first nine months was $2.14 billion, up 4%. The Trade Desk cut about 15% of its global workforce, 15 in the quarter. And the CFO, Nate Olmsted, said the cuts will save more than $100 million in 2027. CEO Jeff Green opened the call by welcoming back co-founder David Pickles, who expanded role AdWeek reported last week. Green called the 2026 elections the company's biggest political cycle yet, notable for being a midterm, not a presidential year. Political was a mid-single-digit percentage of Q3, and Olmsted expects that share to rise slightly in Q4. Some product in mixed detail, joint business plans with agencies and brands rose more than 30% year over year by the end of Q3, with more than 100 more in the pipeline. Its agentic AI model, COA, improved cost per acquisition by a median of 21% over the prior model in A-B tests across 62 campaigns. Video, including CTV, was in the low 50% of the business, mobile in the high 20s, and the display in the low double digits. Audio was about 7% and grew faster than any other channel. For our audience, Olmsted said CBG and auto advertisers remain under pressure while medical and health spending was strong. One more line. Green said in the past that acquisitions sometimes made sense, but often become disaster distractions. On this call, he said, we are always looking. I will transparently say we're looking more now than we historically have, partly because I just think there's a bunch of opportunity in the market. He did not specify what kinds of deals would be opportunities. What do we see here? Well, three threads. First, CBG Advertisers under pressure lines up with what we heard from Colgate Palm Olive a couple episodes ago with the U.S. consumer squeezed in category soft. Second, AI is both the pitch and the cost story. COA is the efficiency headline, and a 15% workforce cut is the other side of that coin. The same compression unilever described when concept development went from five months to three hours, as they detailed in their investors event that I attended. Third, our read only since Green gave no specifics, a trade desktop that's looking more actively for deals fits the consolidation theme from story one, especially in the ad tech that powers commerce media. Sri, last story to you.

Sri

All right. Drone delivery, a fascination word in the industry for the last 10 years, is starting to slowly heat up finally. And this is our last story for today, and it's what you can actually see coming overhead. Walmart is adding 300 more drone delivery sites across the country, an expansion of its partnership with Zipline that started in 2021. According to the company, Walmart has already made more than 2 million deliveries by drone. Tens of thousands of Walmart edits are eligible for drone delivery in the areas where the service is available. And Walmart points out that 90% of Americans live within 10 miles of a Walmart store. Do you know that, Peter? 90%? 10 miles. Customers in those areas will see drone as a delivery option in the Walmart app or on Walmart.com. We gotta try this out when we travel rurally through the country for our work. So they can do that in the Walmart app or Walmart.com and they can also order through the Zipline app. Deliveries are made to front yards, backyards, driveways, etc. Greg Cathy, Walmart's SPC SVP of e commerce fulfillment transformation says we see customers try drone delivery for the novelty and then continue to come back to it for convenience when they need something in just a few minutes. He added that Walmart stores put it close to the communities it serves, and that with Zipline it can build on that proximity of closeness. What is our lens on the CPG guys? This is a store as a fulfillment node, and it's quick commerce at its best. What is our lens here on the CPG guys? This is a store as a fulfillment node, and it's QuickCommerce. American style. Unilever said QuickCommerce has grown about 55% a year since 2024, and Walmart is building its version using the port when it already has. A related P2PI headline on the page says Amazon is expanding drone delivery to nearly 500 US cities. So the race is on full speed. For brands, the questions are practical. Which items are in the drone eligible assortment? And are yours part of it? How do you show up when the order starts in the app and the shopper wants it in minutes via drone? The article doesn't say how advertising fits, so that's an open question to be answered via Walmart Connect, and we'll try to bring you that answer sometime in the future. And it brings us back to story one because last mile and media are converging. DoorDash and Instacart are building scale on one side, and Walmart is building it with its old stores and drones on the other. Peter, wrap us up, please.

PVSB

Thanks, Shreed. That's it for the Commerce Rift this week. Reminder to catch up on our recent episodes: Amazon's Julie Halleluck, the Unlocked Podcast Crossover with our friends Austin and Elizabeth, the second episode of our new podcast on the rise, featuring Josh Runs from Genesis X. Links are in the show notes. If anything we cover today sparks a thought, drop it in the comments. We read them all. And if you're not already following us on LinkedIn, Instagram, TikTok, Facebook, and YouTube, well, now is the time. See you next week.